QUOTE (JustSteve @ Nov 16 2009, 09:35 PM)

I've been lurking for awhile but wanted to throw out a possibility...
For the last year or so I had my "and they lived happily ever after" ending - all the characters get their post-Monk lives, Monk solves the Trudy case, Monk finds true love, Monk gets his badge, and better emotionally. But a couple of recent scenes made me think of an alternative ending. It's probably wrong, but interesting (to me)...
At the end of Mr. Monk and the Dog, when he was with the killer in his apartment Monk said "I know" and it sounded very empathetic to me. My thought was, could Monk know what it's like to accidentally kill the woman he loved? Not that he's the guy, but maybe he did something, or didn't do something that contributed to Trudy's death - a major accident.
At the end of Mr. Monk goes Camping, we were reminded that Monk can be delusional, hallucinate, or whatever he does. He's done that before (Alice Cooper was the guy).
So could it be... After all of the loose ends are tied, Monk solves the Trudy case, but then realizes his contribution to Trudy's death and has a major breakdown. The final scene... The main characters (except Monk) is told by a doctor something like, "It looks like this is permanent, he will always be like this". Then it shows Monk and what "like this" is like... He has a big smile on his face. Then we see what Monk sees... He's with Trudy, happy and they will always be together - never alone again. And that would be the perfect time for him to open his gift, with Trudy around to share it with him.
I'm not really sure that I could be happy with that ending.
As for Monk's empathy at the end of Dog, I think it's been established that Monk suffers from survivor's guilt, he feels guilty about Trudy's death regardless of the fact that he had nothing to actually do with it, like at the end of Actor when he seemed to feel that if he had just gone with Trudy that morning, he could have somehow saved her, even though there was no way that David Ruskin could have known if Trudy asked Adrian to go with her, and Ruskin's story actually goes against what we've heard about that morning from people who were actually there.