I think we can all agree that Hornstock and little-boy cat need to come back.

I kinda like Hiltz Kooler (i know i'm not spelling that right) as like a villain with a vendetta against shawn and gus, although that would be going into some new territory but i think it would be interesting.

I'm not sure that Hiltz Kooler would be out of jail yet.

Horntsock and the little boy cat definatly should come back! I loved them both. Maybe Mcnab will ask shawn and gus to babysit the little boy cat.

hahaha! yea, when McNabb goes on his honeymoon

I'd like to see Trish Conners come back. She played well off the two guys. The characters have known each other since they were kids, so I'm sure the writers could make some intriguing stories for her. I liked the way the guys competed for her, and it would be fun to see her dating either one of them. Of course, Shawn should end up with Jules, but this would be a good relationship to stick in there while we're waiting for the inevitable Shawn/ Jules hook-up. They can't get together too soon without ruining everything!
I also liked Jessica, played by Dulé Hill's wife. They've obviously got chemistry, and I loved Jessie with Gus! She was mad at Gus last time we saw her, but I'd love to see that relationship work out
I really want a story about McNabb. The boycat could be a big part of that one.
I also want Alice Bundy to escape and come after Shawn. That would be SWEET.

haha! great ideas!

i love the one with McNabb and Dulé Hill's wife. she played the roll very well.

i never realized that she plays a blind woman on Fantastic 4, the rock dudes' girlfriend...i'm pretty sure i'm probably the only one in psych fandom that didn't know that off the bat. *blush*

I want Officer Allen, the woman Shawn got his idea to become a psychic from, back. She was on a few episodes in season one but then she disappeared.

yea! i want her back too! i loved her!

"Magic touch. Boop."

hahahahaha!!!

Mrs. Pickles too. She also kind of disappeared after the first season.

haha i always picture Dulé in scary sherry when he's talking to the housekeeper and hes crying like MRS PICKLEEESSSS ! hahaha yeah

personally, i think that Lucinda should come back.
i think it'd be interesting for her to like be asked to work on a case with Carlton while Juliet is doing something else, maybe with Shawn and Gus.
and like Jules is still around the station though, and she gets to see how Calton felt about Lucinda.
and itd better help her understand Lassiter. i think thatd be a great step up in their partnership.
and i think it'd be helpful for Lucinda to see that her leaving turned out to benefit a lot of other people. If Lucinda never left, then you know, Shawn and Gus wouldnt have gotten to know Juliet who turned out to be a friend, and as us Shules shippers know.... thered be no Shawn/Juliet goodness!
and ya know i think itd also probably be some nice closure for Anne Dudek.
cuz she was basically told, hey you dont have any chemistry with these guys so we recast the role and this girl got it who's 5 years younger than you.

idk i just think lucinda would be nice for like an emotional episode.

Hornstock should definatly come back, he was awesome.

I Think we need the Federals from Psy vs. Psy to come back. *Laughs at remembering Mildred*
I agree, we at least need to SEE the boy cat and Hornstock. Perhaps Uncle Burton.

Shawn's mom and cheif Vic's sister. Bar and Lass would make a perfect couple.

I love to see Abigail back. There should be some romance between her and Shawn after high school reunion. Maybe make Juliet a little jealous.

I know! If you watch Shawn vs the Red Phantom, the face that Hiltz Cooler makes were like "I am going to kill you" Definitely, he needs to come back!

i agree with you. i want to see more of the sibling rivalry.

I would love to see the crazy detective (goocheberg?) that partnered up with carlton in scary sherry i think it was.

I totally think that Hornstock needs to come back! He was awesome, and so was the Chief's sister!!!

-Beth

I guess I'm with the majority here. My picks would be Hornstock and Chief Vick's sister.

Though I've also got a soft spot for Emily Bloom from "Black & Tan".

TOTALLY agree. How's this for a scenario:

Abigail goes to the police because she's being stalked by a former student (she's a teacher, right?). Anyway, she and Shawn immediatly hit it off again, he gets put on her case, and they end up getting close. Juliet gives him a hard time and confronts him about getting personally involved with a client (she is a little too upset over this). Shawn nabs the stalker but it shakes Abigail up, as she is not used to dealing with this sort of thing on a regular basis they way Shawn is. Abigail and Shawn go their separate ways at the end, and Shawn and Juliet both realize that Juliet cares more about Shawn than she thought, or is willing to admit.
Oh, and this would be a great way to bring up Shawn's shooting skills that we haven't seen since the pilot. I can't really see him hurting someone seriously, much less killing anyone, but maybe someone is holding a gun an Abigail or something and he shoots them through the hand or something.

I'm way too into this.