In "Mr Monk Buys a House"

Randy says he "was" an Eagle Scout. If he actually was an Eagle Scout he would know that once an Eagle Scout, always an Eagle Scout.

As in, I (as in me) was a Boy Scout until 1976, but I am and always will be an Eagle Scout.

Sorry for the Monkism, but once a fanatic.........................!!

I noticed that to...I am a star scout..

I'm pretty sure he was drummed out after the big community project. Thus "was".

Let's make up an Eagle Scout project for Randy!
I'll start:

He built a built a permanent bandstand in the town park. (Always thinking ahead to the Randy Disher project!)

Charity Bonfire for the Fire Department - the wind shifted. Spot got out all right...