Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: The Monkish Attention To Detail Game.
USA Network Forums > USA Network Originals > Monk
Pages: 1, 2
monkophile1
QUOTE (Monkwriter @ Jul 28 2008, 01:35 PM) *
You're right! Good eye!

Here's a big question. In "On The Run PT. 2, Adrian and Natalie take Rollins' car. Natalie obviously left hers at the car wash. They still have Rollins car at Folsom prison, visiting Dale but when they arrive in Riverton, CA they have Natalie's car again. Surely they didn't go back to Nevada just to get her car before going to stop a boming in Riverton. There would have been no time!! blink.gif


I noticed this car problem in On the Run pt. 2 also. Monk says to take Rollin's car so he can't get away. Then you see them going through Rollin's things, which they could have done at a rest stop. The only thing that makes sense to me is if they each drive a car.

I like this thread. You are all very observant.
Monkwriter
QUOTE (chipe @ Jul 29 2008, 04:22 PM) *
Monkwriter, you can always (usually) get pictures from Google Image Search or IMDb page for the actor:
http://images.google.com/images?gbv=2&...G=Search+Images

http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=htt...%3Doff%26sa%3DG


Thanks Chipe, I have done that but not recently. Perhaps I'll find some new pics. cool.gif
Monkwriter
QUOTE (monkophile1 @ Jul 29 2008, 06:57 PM) *
I noticed this car problem in On the Run pt. 2 also. Monk says to take Rollin's car so he can't get away. Then you see them going through Rollin's things, which they could have done at a rest stop. The only thing that makes sense to me is if they each drive a car.

I like this thread. You are all very observant.


Also regarding "On The Run Prt 1" The powder that blows off the bullet proof vest Monk is wearing was too obvious. Why did they not use blood packs to make it seem real, for the act to trick Rollins and from a tech stand point? When I saw Monk get shot, the powder gave it all away. Still an awesome set of eps, but I'm into reality, if they want to go that far. Wouldn't Rollins have questioned the lack of blood splatter on the pier? Maybe he was close enough to the railing and fell fast enough, but from the looks of it, the impact of the rounds pushed him back at least two steps for him to get to the railing. Even though Monk was acting, the rounds were real and so was the impact. cool.gif
kees_lady
QUOTE
Also, Natalie's character is portrayed as someone who had a hard time getting paid for her services by Mr. Monk. Earlier in the episode, they were arguing about whether her night of reorganizing his drawer was work or fun and the fact that Monk still owed her $1,800. Despite all that, however, did you notice immediately after the Audi commercial ran during the show, the next scene was Natalie and Monk sitting in a 2008 Audi A8? This is about an $80,000 car and a fairly big move from a Jeep Grand Cherokee! Apparently, Natalie's got some money coming in from somewhere!


I'm sorry but this is just plain nit-picking. Audi has chosen to use Monk as their way of advertising their line of vehicles. Any implication that Natalie can't afford one beats all logic since this isn't about whether Natalie is an heiress or not. It's Audi's way of getting their vehicles seen by over a million people who watch this series, the advertising pays the actors salaries.

Why is this always such a big deal when a car company picks up advertising on this series...everyone should know it has nothing to do with Natalie's income from Monk or her families money, it's all about getting Audis advertised on a very popular series. mad.gif
Steve57
QUOTE (kees_lady @ Jul 30 2008, 03:06 AM) *
I'm sorry but this is just plain nit-picking. Audi has chosen to use Monk as their way of advertising their line of vehicles. Any implication that Natalie can't afford one beats all logic since this isn't about whether Natalie is an heiress or not. It's Audi's way of getting their vehicles seen by over a million people who watch this series, the advertising pays the actors salaries.

Why is this always such a big deal when a car company picks up advertising on this series...everyone should know it has nothing to do with Natalie's income from Monk or her families money, it's all about getting Audis advertised on a very popular series. mad.gif


The name of the thread is "Attention to detail." Of course everyone realizes that companies pay to place their products in movies and TV series as a way of public promotion. I merely pointed out the irony of Natalie's character, written on the show as one that struggles to get paid by the frugal Mr. Monk, magically being seen driving an $80,000 car immediately after the car manufacturer's commercial runs. Lighten up!!! cool.gif
Monkwriter
QUOTE (BfloGal @ Jul 28 2008, 06:47 PM) *
You're also an encouragable shipper. smile.gif

I'm not sure if Monk has changed, if TS has just not totally gotten into the role yet, or if the writers just haven't given him a whole lot of opportunities to be Monkish yet -- I'm waiting to decide, but he does seem a little different -- a little more in control. I kind of like it.

But weighing in on the "going all the way" issue -- I think it was totally in-character to say. I'm a little younger than Monk, but there was a lot of pressure in school to be sexually active. Anyone who wasn't was a prime candidate for mocking. I'd imagine Monk was exactly that -- for that reason and many others. I think the inner child in Monk just wanted his old classmates to know that he had 'caught up' -- and he would have used the euphemism commonly used in his teen years. Monk is a genius in many ways, and a child in many others. In dating and sexuality, his maturity level is probably closer to a teen's than a 49 year old.

I was actually a little more surprised that he now uses the word sex -- he didn't seem to at the beginning of the show -- and now he uses it inappropriately -- throwing it in front of words like affair, lover, and prostitute. (In comparison, I've never heard my very Monkish husband use the word at all -- and we've been married for 22 years)


If I may, I'd like to revisit the Trudy death continuity thing. I couldn't find the previous conversation. Anyway, In Genius, Monk said Trudy couldn't speak and Leland said he was there. However, in Mrs. Monk, when Natalie asked Leland if he was there when Trudy died, he said no. He got there an hour later and then he told Natalie she talked to a paramedic before she died. Continuity? It doesn't match with the rest of the story.
By the way, How do I get a new thread on this topic going? Is it the new topic button? I have a Cobra continuity issue. Still learning the forum. Thanks Bflo! cool.gif
BfloGal
I don't know if this is a continuity problem or not but...

Did anyone else notice in Mr. Monk Gets Lotto Fever that, during the news cast about the lotto scandal, that the mic was from channel 6, and the screen said they were watching channel 13, all the while they were in Monk's apartment, and his TV should have been on channel 10. blink.gif

Not a biggie -- I know that sometimes stations use the feed from others, but it kind of struck me as odd.
Kawasakifan
Perhaps this thread should be renamed more appropriately "Monkish Attention to Inconsistencies."

Ironically it is one of the few threads that has co-existed throughout nearly each season.

Although it might turn off true devotees of detective series who might consider these "details" as unacceptable sloppiness, I wonder why it has persisted? Maybe the writers are devilishly trying to test our own detective skills?
alex455
QUOTE (Monkwriter @ Aug 2 2008, 11:16 PM) *
If I may, I'd like to revisit the Trudy death continuity thing. I couldn't find the previous conversation. Anyway, In Genius, Monk said Trudy couldn't speak and Leland said he was there. However, in Mrs. Monk, when Natalie asked Leland if he was there when Trudy died, he said no. He got there an hour later and then he told Natalie she talked to a paramedic before she died. Continuity? It doesn't match with the rest of the story.
By the way, How do I get a new thread on this topic going? Is it the new topic button? I have a Cobra continuity issue. Still learning the forum. Thanks Bflo! cool.gif

I think that Trudy could speak but only for a few minutes...she told "Bread and Butter" to the paramedic but when Monk got there she couldn't speak. As I remember from the Genius episode Monk said " I got there almost too late"
I also think that Leland wasn't with Monk and Trudy in the hospital. Trudy probably died in the way to hospital or in the hospital few minutes later. What Leland meant by that he got there an hour later could meant that he got to the hospital when Trudy was...you know...dead. Monk and Leland probably arrived to the crime scene (to the parking garage) when the paramedics were taking Trudy to the hospital and then Monk just run to her and she couldn't speak so she took Monk hands in hers and Leland witnessed it. Leland as the Captain (I think he was Monks boss already) must've stayed on the crime scene to help everything secure...and then he arrived to the hospital...(an 1 hour later)

I hope you understand what I mean and how I see the Trudy's story continuity....
From my point of view everything is ok with the continuity...everything match perfectly...at least for me...
If something still doesn't match for you please let me know
BfloGal
QUOTE (alex455 @ Aug 3 2008, 07:37 AM) *
I think that Trudy could speak but only for a few minutes...she told "Bread and Butter" to the paramedic but when Monk got there she couldn't speak. As I remember from the Genius episode Monk said " I got there almost too late"
I also think that Leland wasn't with Monk and Trudy in the hospital. Trudy probably died in the way to hospital or in the hospital few minutes later. What Leland meant by that he got there an hour later could meant that he got to the hospital when Trudy was...you know...dead. Monk and Leland probably arrived to the crime scene (to the parking garage) when the paramedics were taking Trudy to the hospital and then Monk just run to her and she couldn't speak so she took Monk hands in hers and Leland witnessed it. Leland as the Captain (I think he was Monks boss already) must've stayed on the crime scene to help everything secure...and then he arrived to the hospital...(an 1 hour later)

I hope you understand what I mean and how I see the Trudy's story continuity....
From my point of view everything is ok with the continuity...everything match perfectly...at least for me...
If something still doesn't match for you please let me know


This makes sense to me -- I only have one minor qualm about this as the scenario --

If Monk held her hand, and was with her when she died, how could he have been convinced for an hour and a half that she was alive in Mrs. Monk?

Oh, well... it's television.

I suppose Monk may have ridden in the ambulance, but had been separated at the hospital?
alex455
QUOTE (BfloGal @ Aug 3 2008, 07:43 AM) *
This makes sense to me -- I only have one minor qualm about this as the scenario --

If Monk held her hand, and was with her when she died, how could he have been convinced for an hour and a half that she was alive in Mrs. Monk?

Oh, well... it's television.

I suppose Monk may have ridden in the ambulance, but had been separated at the hospital?

We don't know if Trudy Monk died in the ambulance or in the hospital but you ansked very good question.
She could die in the hospital ER room...we don't know that yet but maybe the Trudy's story line will be tell whole in one episode...
Monkwriter
QUOTE (BfloGal @ Aug 3 2008, 04:43 AM) *
This makes sense to me -- I only have one minor qualm about this as the scenario --

If Monk held her hand, and was with her when she died, how could he have been convinced for an hour and a half that she was alive in Mrs. Monk?

Oh, well... it's television.

I suppose Monk may have ridden in the ambulance, but had been separated at the hospital?


Entirely possible, even though he was the husband, they wouldn't have allowed him in the trauma cubicle until she was stable and they would have thrown paperwork at him, so he couldn't have been with her the whole time.

New thought on a new ep. "Takes A Punch" What's up with the sweat suit? He had a normal one for "Marathon Man"? And why is he so uncoordinated when in "On the Run" he was entirely coordinated? Adrenaline or as he said, he was highly motivated might answer for prt. 1 but in two he wasn't on adrenaline nessesarily. Don't get me wrong. The scenes on the USA previews are incredibly funny! I was laghing hysterically! Anyway, where'd his grey sweat suit go?, and remember how he danced circles around Sharona?
Any thoughts on those inconsistancies? cool.gif
Jen_of_Oz
In Mr Monk is at Your Service, in the scene where the assistant housekeeper comes to his room to get his measurements, there is a mirror in the background and you can see the tape lines on the floor in it.
kees_lady
Just my thoughts here but to me putting Monk in the flamboyant purple suit was paying tribute to the boxing theme of the episode. Boxers often wear flamboyant colors as their signature so purple would be Monk's sissy color. As for his athletic skills, he was asked to pass a pysical exam and Adrian has problems when he is confronted with doing something so normal. His anxiety gets in his way when he has to think about doing something but when he is just tossed into a situation, like he was when he spotted the hitman with the rifle, he doesn't have time to think and just reacts.

As for the whole was Monk there when Trudy died scenario; since each episode is written by a different writer I think they should have a 'Trudy timeline' they use to keep the Trudy facts consistent. It would sure make it a lot easier on all of us.

Monkwriter
QUOTE (kees_lady @ Aug 11 2008, 10:15 AM) *
Just my thoughts here but to me putting Monk in the flamboyant purple suit was paying tribute to the boxing theme of the episode. Boxers often wear flamboyant colors as their signature so purple would be Monk's sissy color. As for his athletic skills, he was asked to pass a pysical exam and Adrian has problems when he is confronted with doing something so normal. His anxiety gets in his way when he has to think about doing something but when he is just tossed into a situation, like he was when he spotted the hitman with the rifle, he doesn't have time to think and just reacts.

As for the whole was Monk there when Trudy died scenario; since each episode is written by a different writer I think they should have a 'Trudy timeline' they use to keep the Trudy facts consistent. It would sure make it a lot easier on all of us.

I see what you're saying about the suit, but Kevin Dorfman didn't know about the boxer, nor did Monk at that point but it may be one of those writer symbolism tools within but unbeknownst to the characters. Of course I do see the difference in his thinking about doing something and JUST doing it. Although, he did stop to think about the escalator and how to get to it, but of course he was on adrenaline at that point as well.
All I know is, the more I watch this season, the more I enjoy it and the more I lagh at the "Punch" episode. "Underwater looks like it's going to be really good as well.! Can't wait, Friday is too far off!!! huh.gif Here, here on the timeline! cool.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.