Post Episode Commentary (Spoiler alert)
I had thought this might be a fun one -- and I was right. I'm watching the episode again (third time as I write), so I don't leave anything out.
I had some initial apprehensions. The episode descriptions had said he was going to revert back to his nine year old state -- when he was happier. And that kind of bothered me. His father left when he was eight, and we saw in the previous episode that he was holding the family together at that point -- how could that have been a happier time? My other concern was that they showed him being messy and silly -- and from depictions in past episodes, we learned he was anything but. But I thought they handled that well -- explaining that it was a wish-fulfillment, and
that I could understand -- and even identify with.
I think 'Takes His Medicine' was another episode that dealt with wish fulfillment -- eating hamburgers, swimming in a pool, etc, and 'Gets Hypnotized' followed in the same vein. I had often wondered how Natalie might have responded to 'the Monk', and had hoped that she would have been more compassionate and understanding of that. And I think she was -- to some extent. She made him pancakes -- even offering him some after he was out of it. I would have suspected that, after she realized what was going on, that Natalie, who had been encouraging him to have more wonder at the world, would have supplied him with more resources to explore his fantasy childhood. And perhaps she did -- someone had to buy him crayons or paint to decorate Hoppy's box. And I do like to see Monk experiencing the things he never did.
Randy was good in this episode. For those who love to see him do well -- proficient in his job and not a total goofball, this was good one. He was authoritative and sounded like a cop for a good portion of this episode (shall we call him a gum shoe?) but was still Randy enough to be chewing gum the whole eppy, and to give Monk 5 dollars to eat it off a shoe.
Harold is always fun to see -- I am wondering, along with several others from last night's chat, if he will now start seeing Dr. Bell, since his first therapist resulted in his arrest.
Now, I thought Disher-mint was funny, but I knew when Stottlemeyer spit it out, that it was going to end up in evidence somehow. (Side note: Apparently now Disher has a basement -- I thought he had been living in an apartment.) And I also suspected when Susan was missing, that she had set it up. When the husband was killed -- I knew it was premeditated murder. But the mystery didn't disappoint me, somehow. I was a little surprised that neither Disher or Stottlemeyer recognized the gum on Susan's shoe -- but I think that can be attributed to their distraction with Monk.
I know nothing about hypnotism, but suspect that the type of hypnosis on this eppy is more akin to that which is seen in shows for entertainment. (There is an audio buzz in the background during most of the hypnosis scene. I'm not sure if it was supposed to be a part of the sound effects, but I found it a bit irritating -- but only after the third time I watched it.) I'm sure we'll get some experts on hypnotism sign up just to tell us what they did wrong, so I'll leave that to them. But he was a quack -- so anything he did was within the realm of my suspension of disbelief. I was willing.
I loved the frog -- and I loved the fact that "me and Natalie" were the only ones who could touch it. Now the balloon they didn't get enough mileage out of IMHO -- I was waiting for helium voice -- and we didn't get it.

But Tony was great in this episode, as usual.
For those keeping score, I think this is actually the third time Natalie called him 'Adrian.' Once in 'Red Herring', and then again at the end of 'Gets Drunk.'
The childish false summation was classic Monk -- just as funny as the Alice Cooper-wing back chair summation. The actors portraying the Larkins were wonderful in that scene. I loved how that whole thing came down -- Susan lying on the mattress, exaggeratedly kicking her legs and taunting. The hubby hitting himself on the head. It was playing in Monk's head like hammy kids would act out the scene. Whoever thought of that gets a special award from me --- it was pure comedic genius.
I loved the line, "She is a liar, Stottlemeyer." And I loved Monk's juvenile detective skills. Figuring out that Larkin and his girlfriend wanted to "go on a honeymoon and kiss" based on the fact that he wasn't afraid of her cooties, was really hysterical, as was his conclusion that she was not locked up for three days since no one could survive that long without television, and his assertion that a girl couldn't beat up a boy. LOL.
And we got the line "Here's what happened" back again -- YAY!
But in the end, I would have suspected that he would have been slightly better after his exercise in wish-fulfillment -- happier, slightly better adjusted. I did like the fact that he got up to look at the bird outside his window, but I would have been happier and more encouraged had he smiled -- even slightly. But I guess that wouldn't be status quo, would it? -- and poor Mr. Monk must remain miserable for our viewing pleasure. "I don't get it" made me sad.
This will end up in my list of top ten favorites.