SEPTEMBER 11, 2001
CHAPTER 10It was dusk as Annie drove down her street, and lights were going on inside houses. But as her house came into view, she saw that Bobby’s car was not in the driveway and there were no lights on. She pulled into the driveway, shut off the engine, and just sat for a moment. She could see that Janey’s car was missing next door and wondered where she had gone. Annie had sent her an e-mail telling her that she should be home no later than 8:00 PM. The children must be with her, because they probably would have seen her pull up and come running out if they were in Janey’s house. She looked up at the house that she loved so much, the house she and Bobby had been so proud to buy, the house that contained so many happy memories. She stared at the dark windows and the tears threatened to fall again. She laid her forehead against the steering wheel and said another prayer for Bobby.
She got out and walked up to the front door. There was Janey’s note for Bobby; she pulled it off as she unlocked the door and opened it. She stepped in and closed the door, not turning on any lights just yet. As she turned back to the living room, she gasped at the dark outline of a man sitting on the landing of the stairs.
“Bobby!” Annie dropped her purse, keys, and the note in a pile on the floor and rushed to where he was sitting in the dark. She knelt down on the step just below him, threw her arms around his waist, and buried her face (and her tears) against his broad chest. Bobby didn’t say anything. He just put one hand to the back of her head and put his other arm around her shoulders. He buried his face in her hair and held her tightly. They held each other in the dark silence of their home for a long time.
Annie pulled back to look up at his face. She saw dust in his dark, curly hair and on his clothing. He had removed his jacket and tie and loosened the collar of his shirt. His black leather slip-on shoes were also covered with dust. She reached up and held his face between her hands. He looked down at her, still silent. She couldn’t read his expression in the dark, but she could feel the dampness on his face. She pulled his head down to her and planted soft kisses all over his face, coming at last to his lips. He pulled her tightly against him again as they kissed. When the kiss ended he leaned his forehead against hers and closed his eyes. Annie wrapped her arms around his back again and held him closely.
Finally she said, “I’ve been so worried about you. I was terrified you were in one of the buildings. I kept trying to call you or at least call the squad room, but I couldn’t get through.”
He sighed and stood up, pulling her up with him. They walked over to the couch and sat down. Bobby pulled her onto his lap and kissed her again. Annie put her arms around him, laid her head against his chest, and stayed silent as he began to talk. It seemed that once he started, he couldn’t stop the memories from tumbling out.
“After I talked to you yesterday morning, the entire squad headed out. We wanted to go to the site, but MCS was sent to do traffic control. Eames and I were directing traffic on Pearl when the first building fell. We heard this rumble and we just stood there watching it. It was unbelievable. And that dust cloud just rose up and spread out towards us. We didn’t get the full force of the blast like they did closer to the site, but the dust spread out and covered everything.
“We stayed there until noon. We tried to keep the street open for emergency vehicles to get through, but we heard that the vehicles that were already there were covered in debris and were useless, and that vehicles coming in couldn’t get close. People were coming out of the area on foot, covered with ash and dust. It looked like a war zone.
“Chain of command was a mess. One PP was supposed to be the command center. But field commanders weren’t keeping in contact. At first it was because the radios had so much chatter that they were useless. And you know the problems with the phones. But even after the radios cleared up, the field commanders just weren’t utilizing One PP. They were setting up command posts and then moving them around. It was hard to find who was in charge.
“Around noon, Captain Deakins found Eames and me. He had some uniforms take over on traffic control and he sent us to Pier 94. Dr. Rodgers was there and the M.E.’s office was setting up a temporary morgue. That’s where we stayed all day and night and into today. They were already bringing bodies in when Eames and I got there.”
Bobby paused. He laid his cheek on the top of Annie’s head and tightened his arms around her. He was holding her so tightly that it was difficult to breathe, but she stayed quiet and let him regroup. Finally he continued.
“It was bad, Babe, really bad.” His voice was so soft it was almost a whisper. “We helped with identifying the bodies. A lot of them had identification on them. The Missing Persons Center brought over pictures that families provided and we identified some that way. But then….th….there….were…..” He stopped again. “There were th….the…body parts.”
He held her tightly again and she could feel his tears falling onto her head and her face. After about ten minutes, Annie pulled away. She sat up and turned so that she was facing him and straddling his lap. She held his face between her hands and looked into his eyes. She knew that the haunted look she saw in them would be there for a long time, probably for the rest of his life whenever he remembered the events of that day. She kissed his wet cheeks.
He sighed and said, “It will take weeks, months to identify them. Some people will probably never be identified. When I finally left, I didn’t even go back to One PP to get my car. I took a cab home. All I wanted was to see you and the kids, and hold you all in my arms. Janey left a note on her door that she and the kids would be back soon. So I just came in here and waited for you to come home.”
Annie kissed him and got up. She turned on a light and went to the kitchen. She poured two glasses of iced tea and bought them out to the living room. She handed Bobby one of the glasses and sat down on the coffee table, facing him. They drank their tea in silence. Bobby put his hand on Annie’s knee and squeezed it lightly.
“The whole time I was in that morgue, I kept thinking about the families. I thought about you and that day you were attacked. When the captain told me what happened and that you were in the hospital I was so scared I couldn’t think straight. It’s a good thing Eames drove me to the hospital; I don’t think I could have found my way. And then I saw you in the ER. You were unconscious and so pale, you…..you looked….” He didn’t finish the thought. “I don’t know what I would have done if….if…you…if I had lost you. There are so many people who are going to hear those words I was so afraid I was going to hear that day….that someone they love is gone.”
He leaned back and held his empty glass with both hands, staring down at the ice cubes. Annie’s eyes filled with tears. This was the first time Bobby had talked about his feelings the day she was attacked. He had been so focused on her and helping her through it that, as usual, he pushed his own feelings and fears aside. She was ashamed to realize that she had been so caught up in her own pain that she had not considered how deeply the attack and the loss of their baby had affected her husband.
“Annie,” he said softly. “I know that just two nights ago I was reminding you about what you believe about God, and I’m glad it helped you get past what happened. But I said the things I did to help you, not because I understand anything about God. Wh…..when I look at what happened yesterday, the magnitude of the devastation, not just here, but in Washington and in Pennsylvania…..” He sighed. “All my study and research into the criminal mind just doesn’t explain what happened yesterday. I at least understand that Martin Ramsay was a victim of the lies his own brain was telling him. But this…I don’t understand this. And all the theological books I’ve read…it just doesn’t make sense. Where’s God, Annie? When thousands of people die in one day, within hours. Where was He?”
Annie took his glass and set both glasses on the coffee table. She looked at him for a long moment before answering.
“Bobby, you’ve read more than I have by theologians and great thinkers who all tried to find an explanation for evil. I don’t have any great intellectual answers. All I know is this: next to life itself, one of the greatest gifts God has given us is freedom of choice. The freedom to choose to follow Him or not. The freedom to choose to do good or to do evil. Without that freedom of choice, worship of God would be meaningless—we would nothing more than programmed robots. So when people choose to do evil things He allows them that freedom. But I believe above everything else that He never stops trying to speak to each and every one of us, to guide us to do what is good. He never stops speaking, whether or not we are willing or capable of hearing Him. Freedom of choice also means we have the freedom to refuse to listen. And if we refuse long enough and often enough, we may not be able to hear Him anymore. He has to let us see the results of the choices we make, good and bad. We need to see that choosing Him, choosing good, is best. Not because He will punish us if we choose wrong, but because we destroy ourselves and others when we choose not to listen to Him.
“I can tell you where He was the day I was attacked. He was right there with me, comforting me and reassuring me of His love. He was there speaking to Martin Ramsay’s delusional mind, urging him to stop. And I can tell you where He was yesterday. He was there with every one of those people. He was trying to speak that same comfort and reassurance to every single victim. He’s with each of their family members right now doing the same thing. And He was with every one of those terrorists, begging them to stop; pleading with them to listen to Him.”
Bobby took both her hands in his and just looked at her. The front door opened just then and all three children ran into the house. Ally was in the lead and launched herself into her Daddy’s arms. Phillip and Andrew were next and all three children squirmed to find a place on his lap. Janey came in carrying a ready-to-bake pizza.
“Bobby! I’m glad you made it home. When I got your e-mail, Annie, that you would be home, I figured you might not have eaten dinner. So the kids and I went and got a pizza for you. I’m going to put it in the fridge for you and then I’ll leave you guys alone. The kids have already had dinner and their baths; they just need to get their pajamas on. Do you both have to go in tomorrow?” Annie and Bobby both nodded and Janey added, “OK, then just drop the kids at my house in the morning and I will see you when you get home tomorrow night.”
Janey put the pizza away, hugged Annie and Bobby, and left. The kids had finally settled into their positions; Ally on Bobby’s lap and the boys on either side.
Phillip asked, “Daddy, did you catch the bad guys who blew up the planes?”
Bobby tousled Phillip’s hair. “Well, some of the bad guys were on the planes and we….we got them. We’ll do our best to get the rest of them.”
Andrew asked, “Did you shoot them?”
“No, we didn’t shoot them. They….died when the planes crashed.”
That seemed to satisfy the twins. Ally sat and looked up at her father solemnly. “We went to Mommy’s hospital and we saw sad people. Mommy says you are going to help find the people in the pictures.”
Bobby glanced at Annie and she explained, “People have been putting missing person fliers on the wall outside the ER.”
“Are you going to find the people?” asked Ally.
“I’m going to try.”
“Did a lot of people die, Daddy?”
Bobby hugged Ally to him and kissed the top of her head. “Yes, Sweetie, a lot of people died.” His eyes met Annie’s and she saw again the haunted look.
The boys were beginning to fidget. The enormity of what had happened was over their heads. But Ally had one more question.
“If we pray really, really hard for the bad guys, will they stop being bad?”
Bobby closed his eyes and didn’t answer right away.
“I don’t know, Ally. Should we ask Mommy to pray?”
“OK.”
So they all held hands and Annie prayed with her family. She prayed for the victims, for the families, for the rescue workers, and for the terrorists. When she finished, the boys, having been quiet long enough, started wrestling. Ally stayed in Bobby’s lap.
Annie said, “Babe, why don’t you go take a shower while I cook the pizza, OK? And you three scoot up to your rooms and get dressed for bed. If you hurry, you can stay up for a little while and watch TV.”
Ally kissed Bobby on the cheek and slid off his lap. All three of the children went upstairs. Bobby reached over, put his hands on either side of Annie’s face, and kissed her. He got up without saying anything and followed the kids up the stairs.
Annie went to the kitchen and put the pizza in the oven. By the time it was done, Bobby had come back downstairs, showered and clean-shaven. The children came down, dressed in their pajamas. Annie turned the TV on for them to watch while she and Bobby ate. It was not easy to find something other than news about the attacks, but she finally found some cartoons. She and Bobby ate in silence and then joined the kids on the couch. They watched the rest of “Spongebob Squarepants” and Annie smiled at Bobby’s pained look. When it ended, there was a brief news report about the attacks. A picture came onscreen of three firefighters raising the United States flag amidst the rubble of the World Trade Center. All five of them were silent as they looked at the poignant picture. The news report ended and Bobby turned the TV off.
He told Annie, “You probably want to take a shower, too. I’ll get the kids in bed.”
She kissed him and went upstairs. She stood in the shower for a long time and let the water wash away some of the stress of the last two days. After getting her pajamas on and French braiding her wet hair, she went into the bedroom. She stopped short when she found all three children in the bed and Bobby reading “The Giving Tree”. Annie smiled and Bobby looked at her sheepishly.
“They wanted to sleep in here tonight”, he said and shrugged.
Annie chuckled at her soft-hearted husband, and slid into bed. Bobby continued to read for a few minutes, until the kids all seemed ready for sleep. Bobby turned off the light. Annie propped herself on her elbow and began singing softly.
Smile though your heart is aching
Smile even though its breaking
When there are clouds in the sky, you’ll get by
If you smile through your fear and sorrow
Smile and maybe tomorrow
Youll see the sun come shining through for you
Light up your face with gladness
Hide every trace of sadness
Although a tear may be ever so near
Thats the time you must keep on trying
Smile, whats the use of crying?
Youll find that life is still worthwhile
If you just smile
Thats the time you must keep on trying
Smile, whats the use of crying?
Youll find that life is still worthwhile
If you just smile
All three children were breathing evenly when she finished. She lay back down and tried to find a comfortable position. Bobby reached across the three sleeping children and took her hand. He laced his fingers with hers and squeezed gently.
“I love you Annie Paine”, he whispered.
“I love you Bobby Goren”, she whispered back.
The EndI want to thank two special friends for all their help with this story.
Spookycc, for her help as my beta. She caught all (I hope!) of my mistakes. She also provided me with invaluable information on 9/11. She provided links to web sites about the events in New York, the NYPD, and the missing person fliers. She also let me bounce ideas off of her and gave me suggestions.
Judyg helped me over a huge writer’s block when I was trying to write about Annie meeting Bobby’s mother for the first time. One brief comment from Judy was all I needed for the dam to break and the idea to flow.
Thanks so much girls!
The poem, “How Do I Love Thee” was written by Elizabeth Barrett Browning. The lyrics of “Smile” were written by John Turner and Geoffrey Parsons and recorded by Nat King Cole.
As a Californian who was 3,000 miles away from the events of this day, researching and writing this story became a very emotional experience for me. I hope that I have not offended anyone who experienced these events first hand. To everyone who was in New York, Washington, or Pennsylvania that day, please know that my thoughts and prayers were with you on September 11, 2001 and they are still with you today.