If Monk had been a classic movie, who would be cast in the roles?

My cast:

Monk-James Stewart
Natalie- Jean Arthur
Stottlemyer- Spencer Tracy
Disher- Eddie Bracken
Sharona- Barbara Stanwyck

Yea i like a couple of those. Disher and Eddie Bracken. Thats really good. And a couple more i agree with too.



RandyDisherProjectFan!

This is too cool! I love classic movies. Let me think....

Monk - If James Stewart wasn't available, I think William Powell or a 'nerded up' Cary Grant.
Natalie - Has to be the girl next-door, so I'm thinking Myrna Loy.
Stottlemeyer - Spencer Tracy works for me, too.
Disher - Keenen Wynn
Sharona - I like Barbara Stanwyck too, but Ginger Rogers could also do a decent Sharona...or Betty Grable.
Julie - a young Elizabeth Taylor has my nod over Judy Garland or Shirley Temple.

Monk -- Gary Coleman ("Whatchu talkin' bout, Leland?")

Stottlemeyer -- Sylvester Stallone ("Eh, yo, Adrian!! Monk, that is!") LOL

My cast:

Monk-Jerry Lewis
Natalie- Myrna Loy
Stottlemyer- Ward Bond
Disher- Joe E Brown
Sharona- Teresa Wright

Good choices.

Monk-I too, would choose James Stewart, great actor!

Natalie-Doris Day

Stottlemeyer-Sean Connery (I really don't know...)

Disher- Rock Hudson

Sharona-Jean Harlow

!chik!