QUOTE (ireactions @ Feb 6 2008, 10:41 PM)

Well, I didn't feel ripped off when I replaced my VHS cassettes of "Casablanca" and "You've Got Mail" with DVD versions. I think a bluray/HD DVD set wouldn't really qualify as a ripoff. It's a different format. High definition television screens will eventually become commonplace, and when that happens, it'll probably be expected that video image detail is up to the standard of what the screens can show. Normal videos on a high definition television screen can often look grainy, blurry and washed out because the lines of resolution are being stretched by the high definition display.
People don't generally own HD TVs right now, however, and aren't really aware of the difference. As someone who watches his movies on a flatscreen 16:9 monitor hooked up to a laptop, it doesn't matter to me personally. But I imagine there will eventually be a preference for the HD format.
- IBrahim Ng
Me too Ibrahim, I mean once you've given up expecting laserdisc quality on a CRT and analogue in general, and settled for Big Youtube/Digital, you can easily settle for a 400MB divx file, and follow the story well enough. But to get anywhere near laserdisc quality HD is the way (I know about all the differences in resolution blah blah blah) but for sheer depth of image it was generally better, any specialist will tell you the same. If you ever owned one you'll know what I mean.
Either way theres still the problem of which format to release it on.
To slow piracy I think they should be region free if its Bluray, for HDDVD it does'nt matter because everything is region free anyway. They should also include 'digital copies' as seen with the region 1 Die Hard 4 disc, to allow easy 'legal' transfer to portable devices.
Anyway to answer my own questions:-
Q1 Yes, I would definately buy because SD just does'nt cut it on a flat screen.
Q2 Extras, I think they should include retrospective documentaries which span all of the seasons and segment them across each season(like the batman beyond series if anyone got those), one documentary for writers/directors, one for cast. Also a 'what could have been' section where writers discuss in-depth, where the show was going next and how they would've concluded the story. Whats next for everyone and Final goodbye's. Best blogs, website videos included.