Pardon me for taking the liberty of combining several of Ms S's statments made in various posts and putting them into one reply post
QUOTE (MsSweden)
I'm a professional fundraiser <<the rest of this post is snipped>>
That's great to hear Ms S! In fact I have another one of my possibly 'crazy' ideas to share with you:
Might I ask you to consider sharing your expertise, wisdom and insight directly with Room To Read, that is if you would feel comfortable doing so? I know they are looking for professionals to join them both in paid positions which they post at
http://www.roomtoread.org/about/employment.html and also in a volunteer capacity. Admittedly they are a young organization and are somewhat inexperienced in how the more established fund raisers at other institutions work but I am certain that they would greatly appreciate your direct input. And as you are a professional fundraiser, perhaps you might be able to assist them beyond the duration of the Frances Goren Library campaign (which will only reach a limited number of the 10 million children they would like to reach by 2010). If the idea interests you, I would be happy to provide you with the contact information of the Chief Operating Officer, Erin Ganju and offer my recommendation of your services to the organization.
I am especially impressed by your ability to write well founded arguments on behalf of making donations to the cause both in this thread and others. I am quite convinced that if you were to offer these invaluable skills directly to Room To Read that they would be excited to either pay for them or accept their donation and to put them to good use in many campaigns.
QUOTE (MsSweden)
She's been contacted privately. <<snipped>> That's why the public post. A last resort.
I'm afraid I didn't receive any PMs from you via the USA board or any emails from you. Am I looking in the wrong places? Could there be a technical glitch with USA (it has eaten a few PMs of mine I thought I sent to others before)? I was offline when you initially posted (I needed to catch some sleep and tend to a cat of mine who is not eating like he should, so my apologies for not more fully reading all your posts sooner). If you would like to contact me directly you can try PMing me again.
As far as my being 'egocentric', a 'glory-seeker' or interested in my own 'self-importance' well that is clearly a matter of opinion and in the eye of the beholder. I don't know if you are also an attorney, but I can say that it would be quite foolish of me to sue you over what is clearly your own opinion, to which you are clearly entitled by law, which you are quite free via the First Amendment of the US Constitution to express, and is one of the areas of defamation law that is well settled. I don't have a valid cause of action in a court of law to sue you because you choose to publically express your unfavorable opinion of me nor am I ignorant enough to do so. So you have no worries there.
I also want to correct a possible misconception you may have about me that was implied in your last post...that I am somehow incredibly rich and out of touch with the giving habits of the working and middle classes. While I will give you the point that I'm not often perceived as anonymous or humble, my personal finances are not as fabulous as my education and law license imply. I didn't come from a rich family (my dad was a career soldier, my mother a high school math teacher) and until I went to college, my family lived a pretty frugal lifestyle.
To this day I happen to be an adherent to the principles of voluntary simplicity. I live on a decidedly lower-to-middle middle class income and while I am well educated and could aggressively go after a much higher income, I choose to earn less, consume less, and deploy my resources in such a way that I can afford my hobbies of collecting and blogging and also to spend more time doing things I love (reading, spending time with my father, socializing informally with neighbors, working only for a few clients I really care about, taking life at a slower pace, etc). I took myself off the fast track professionally for a lot of reasons I won't get into here but I don't regret it. I also practice economies that others might not choose to practice (like I rarely buy new clothes or eat out, I don't have a mortgage, and I am slow to buy cars...in fact I wish I didn't have to own one, but living in the country you can't rely on public transportation). Thanks to my choices I can afford to collect and blog and spend more time with family and friends and what have you. But in my case I highly prize my freedom and my independence and my quirky hobbies and I pay for them by being frugal. And I feel decidely rich and fortunate though my bank balance might not appear as large as you might think. Others I know of may choose differently and I respect their choices so long as the others in question are happy with their choices.
Following in that vein, there are a variety of styles of giving to charities. Some people will be motivated to give money to an organization with no expectation of receiving anything in return. Others like getting a tangible reward for their money. Still others choose to donate goods, services, assets, ideas, time, connections and so on. What I have tried to do in my own admittedly clumsy way is to offer something I can afford to give that was received (to my pleasant surprise) quite enthusiastically by Room To Read. It was refreshing to see that they want to work on this and didn't just counter my offer with 'sorry we only want money'. I can't speak for others, but I am often turned off by charities that are too stringent in the forms of help that they will accept and for those reasons tend not to give money to them. So personally I give a lot to local organizations that tend to be more flexible with donations (like I anonymously donate many books and DVDs to my public library which operates on a tight budget and is always looking to grow its collections) and to slight organizations that only want cash (which I am cautious in giving out). Others may feel differently and I respect that. I consider all opinions on this topic are valid.
Would I like to write out a $10,000 or a $3000 check to Room To Read and pronounce the Frances Goren Library project a done deal? Of course I would. That however does not fit my finances or my life goals nor does it give the others opportunities to contribute in their own way. I have a lot of respect for a variety of people here who do things differently and I am always interested in hearing what they have to say. I am proud of the fact that CI fans are an intelligent analytical skeptical bunch that for the most part are also tolerant of each others differences.
While we may differ in our opinions on how to fund raise, on how best to help out a cause, the efficacies of charity auctions versus the solicitations of cash donations or what have you, and on how best to solicit the help and support of our fellow fans, I do believe we are playing on the same teams. We both like CI and Room To Read's mission otherwise neither of us would be posting here.
Admittedly I'm the rookie here and you raise valid points about the potential costs to the charity of running an auction while I have been looking primarily at the benefits, namely that the charity creates a new fund raising avenue, stands to gain worldwide exposure and support (and perhaps some sorely needed widespread publicity), and perhaps can inspire others in the entertainment industry to help fulfill their mission with more projects. But I'm looking to bury the hatchet here and not to gore someone else's ox.
So hopefully I've addressed all your points of contention...if I haven't, feel free to raise them privately or publically with me (though I think the majority of readers of this thread might prefer the former)
I hope everyone here has a marvelous weekend
The Vault