Broadcast Nets Thinking Narrowly (click to read the full article)
Excerpt:
QUOTE
Filching shows like Monk from cable is part of the sad trend of preaching to acquire
By David Bianculli -- Broadcasting & Cable, 3/31/2008
The broadcast networks used to make great TV shows. Now, more and more, they remake them instead—or borrow them from a cable network or international source that has already done the tough work of actual creativity.
On April 6, Monk and Psych, two entertaining shows from USA Network, begin a run of weekly repeats on NBC Universal's broadcast sister operation, NBC. This follows the recent, relatively successful decision by CBS to plunder Showtime, one of its own corporate bedfellows, and present first-season reruns of Dexter.
Some shows created for cable should simply stay put. HBO's Deadwood routinely was in my annual top 10, but I can't imagine its language and violence sanitized for a broadcast TV audience. (Ian McShane's character would have to be renamed Al Don't-Swearengen.) For that matter, having seen the unexpurgated versions of HBO's Sex and the City and The Sopranos, I couldn't stomach the edited versions of basic cable's TBS and A&E, respectively. But those telecasts, for the most part, are for people who haven't seen the originals.
Dexter, though, is surprisingly transferable to broadcast TV—at least season one. (Season two, which had a lot more sex, is a different matter.) Psych is such a light-hearted romp, the transfer is easy—and Monk, with Tony Shalhoub as a modern-day Sherlock Holmes with severe obsessive-compulsive disorder, is so made for broadcast TV, it should have been made for broadcast TV.
Monk is a throwback to those classic Universal cop shows of the 1970s, when Kojak and Columbo would solve cases in their own inimitable, entertaining, abrasive way. It's impressive, and laudable, that USA Network developed and began showing Monk six years ago. Conversely, it's very sad that, six years later, its appearance on NBC makes it look fresher than almost anything else presented on that network.
RECYCLED AND REDUNDANT
Think of it. Outside of Heroes (on hiatus) and Friday Night Lights (in limbo), is there a better drama on the NBC schedule than Monk? And at CBS, does any drama series this season compare to Dexter?............