QUOTE (AliceCooper @ Jul 30 2007, 08:49 PM)

No, Liv. Honestly, I have to agree with you there. When people start hooking up then it starts getting weird for me, too. The occasional flirt and "it was nice but it's not going to work out" is alright. But if the show is about a really genius guy with major problems solving murders then the relationship stuff just gets in the way of the heart of the show. Besides, real life is kinda like that. Hit and miss. Sometimes you get lucky for awhile, maybe. Too much romance in this show will distract from the main character and the main concept.
I just watched "Mr. Monk, Private Eye." That was the first time Linda comes on the scene. She is pretty brash but she seemed to be what the Captain needed at the time. Plush she got him into that nice apartment, even if she can spy on him from her balcony. Which is creepy. Well-meaning yet creepy. She doesn't seem too bad. She does say SOB a lot. Realtors…
Anyway, yes. It's true. Too much romance would kill this show. I like it just the way it is.
Exactly, I think that the occasional flirtation exchange is great, but the actual hook up is boring and usually messes things up. I think that it's just best to have as many *possibilities* open as you can, which means that having tension, flirtation and so on is a good thing. Once you start definitely pairing people off and focusing too much on the relationships, you start shutting down possibilities, putting limits on the show and the character growth, especially when you pair two main/recurring characters together. If Adrian and Natalie, for instance, became romantically involved to the point that it was no longer possibility but a definite thing, not only would it be such a big deal that it would have to be a part of just about every episode after that and would hugely change the formula of the show, but there would be no way of going back from that short of Natalie leaving, and not many, if any, options for going forward, there wouldn't be much for the people who liked the idea of Natalie and Randy becoming involved to hope for, or for the people like me, who hoped that they would/could just leave it alone and allow Natalie to continue being seen as a complete and whole person by herself, and an equal part of the team. If Natalie and Adrian stay involved, they've lost the tension and suspense that kept some people watching to see if they would get together, and they have to go forward, where would it lead? Either to Trudy becoming much less important to Adrian, which make a lot of fans upset, or to Adrian and Natalie having a new, and unpleasant kind of tension where Natalie will continually feel like she will never measure up to Trudy in Adrian's eyes, and that will, or should, make a lot of fans angry. Both women deserve better.
I think that a Natalie and Randy thing might have a slightly better chance of not destroying the show, because Randy isn't devoted to another women (dead or alive) in that way, because although they are main characters and important to the show, they aren't the focal point of it, and because we have seen Randy bounce back from so much, and we know that Natalie is tough, that if things didn't work out, they could end the relationship and go on from there, which just isn't possible with Adrian. But I still hope that they don't feel that this is a necessary step or a great idea. I don't want to see Monk de-evolve into a soap opera.