“Never Say Never”
Part 1: The Moment of Truth
It was spring already. The sun was out and every New Yorker was bustling here and there to try and get to where ever they were going to. The sun was out, the weather was warm and all was calm in the city. So what is an SVU detective to do when there are no cases; paper work. The precinct was abnormally quite. Munch, Fin, Elliot and Olivia were all busy looking at case files and computer screens. Munch thought his eyes were going cross eyed.
“That’s it! I am going home. In this day and age, with everything on a computer, it is no wonder that so many people need glasses, contacts and eye surgery.”
“You know what, I am going with you. Maybe I might even be able to spend some time with my son.” Fin then turns to Liv and El. “Hay it’s already 7 o’clock. You guys gonna go home anytime soon?”
Both Elliot and Olivia look up at the same time, which made Munch and Fin laugh.
“No. I think I will stay and finish up. It’s not like I have anything to do.”
“What about you Elliot?”
“No I think I’ll stay and finish up to.”
Both Elliot and Olivia turn back to their work and Fin and Munch leave.
The next thing Olivia notices is the clock.
“Elliot! It’s almost 10 o’clock. We really need to go.”
“Yeah I know. Let’s get the hell out of here.”
They both grab their coats and other items they need in their locker and then start to walk out of the precinct shoulder to shoulder.
“Hay? Do you wanna go and get a drink?”
“No. I just want to go home.”
“Need a ride?”
“You know, I am only about ten blocks. I think I’ll walk.”
“Liv it’s almost 10. There is no way in hell I am gonna let you walk.”
“Let me?”
“Alright, alright.” Elliot throws his hands in the air in a “I give up” kind of way. “But at least let me walk with you.”
She had planed on walking through the park to do some thinking. The company did seem like a nice idea. Walking was a way that Olivia could clear her head and after almost 12 hours of staring at the computer screen and files, she really needed this walk.
“Sure Elliot. That sounds nice.”
“Good because I was going to come any ways.”
“I thought as much.”
They both laughed and left the precinct. As they were walking, Elliot could tell that Olivia had something on her mind. Whenever they were alone, Elliot could sense that Olivia had this nagging question that she wanted to ask him. He never did ask her about it because he felt that she would tell him eventually. However, he thought he would be bold and just go for it.
“What’s bothering you Liv?”
“Huh?”
The two detectives had just entered the park and were starting to walk up a hill. Liv was in her own train of thought and didn’t hear what Elliot said. All she heard was a mumble.
“What’s on your mind?”
“Oh, just stuff.”
Should I ask him? Or am I jumping the gun? Is it any of my business? No I will wait.
“Stuff? O.k. I am not buying it. Something has been nagging at you. What is it?”
“Nothing is bothering me Elliot. Really I’m fine. So how are the kids? I remember you saying something about spending the weekend with them. How did it go?”
She is changing the subject. Why does she do that every time I want to know what is on her mind? Is she hiding something? I’ll answer her question but I am not going to let her slid without telling me what the hell is bothering her.
“The twins are fine. We went and got pizza, saw a movie and talked about school.”
“Great! I am glad the twins are doing good but what about Kathleen? She didn’t go with you?”
“No. She is still mad at me for the divorce. She refuses to talk to me.”
“How can she be mad at you? Kathy is the one who wanted the divorce in the first place.”
Both Olivia and Elliot find an empty bench and sit down. They could feel the cool breeze against their faces and Olivia takes the time to look up at the moon. It is a crescent moon and is so beautiful.
“Yeah well she blames me for Kathy wanting the divorce in the first place. I don’t blame her for thinking that because it’s true. I was never home and when I was, I was off in another world. I never talked about anything and I was never really supportive. No wonder women keep leaving me.”
With that last comment, Olivia turned her attention from the moon to Elliot’s sad expression.
“Not every woman leaves you Elliot. The only woman who has is Kathy.”
“That is not true Liv. You left me twice and Dani left.”
Oh my god! He knew the woman for like 6 weeks! Why the hell does he have to bring her up at all! And why does he keep saying that I left him twice! I didn’t!
“I didn’t leave you twice Elliot. I left once and came back. I am still here, with you, right now.”
“Liv, you asked for a new partner and then you left for you undercover job.”
“Exactly Elliot! It was for the job. I will admit that when I left you the first time it was a mistake! That is why I recanted. I left the second time for the job! I successfully infiltrated and was practically begged by Star to work it. I admit that I should have called but I didn’t have the time! Will you please stop saying that I left you!”
“Alright, I am sorry. Calm down. What got you all wound up?”
“Nothing!”
“Yeah right Liv. Would you just tell me what the hell has been bothering you.”
“I don’t want to talk about it.”
“Liv you know that I am not going to stop asking you until you tell me so…Out with it.”
“Fine, did anything happen between you and Dani? There I asked.”
Ah ha! I knew it! I had a feeling it had something to do with Dani!
“So that is what has been bothering you Liv?”
“You still haven’t answered my question.”
“No. Nothing happened between me and Dani. We kissed but that was it.”
“You kissed! Wow. Talk about moving fast.”
“Look Liv, it was just a kiss. We both realized that it was stupid and then we went our separate ways.”
Olivia was getting frustrated. She knew Elliot was hiding something. Olivia stood up and stared at him. Not an evil stair. But a “I need to know stair.”
“Why did Dani leave? And don’t tell me she couldn’t take the victims because we both know that’s crap.”
“Why does it bother you so much that Dani and I kissed?”
“Please Elliot. Just answer my question.”
Now Elliot was getting upset.
“Dani was unsure if she could continue as an SVU detective. She asked me if I thought she should stay. I told her that I couldn’t decide for her. It had to be her choice. She said goodbye then turned and walked away. The end! There are you happy? Now it’s your turn. Why does Dani bother you so much?”
Olivia knew that this was the time for truth. She needed to tell Elliot how she felt.
Here it goes Olivia. Try not to screw this up and just start slow. Alright I can do this.
Olivia put her hands in her jacket pocket and looked at the trees as she spoke to Elliot.
“When I first started to work at SVU, I was terrified. I was so afraid that I wouldn’t fit in. After I met everyone, I knew that it would be o.k. It took me awhile to get to be 100% comfortable, but I knew that in time I would. When Cragen introduced me as your new partner, I was even more terrified. I had heard your reputation as a cop and I was afraid that I wouldn’t be able to follow. I came to realize that wasn’t the case. You made me fell comfortable. I knew that from the first case we worked on we would be great as partners.”
Olivia, as she spoke, started to get a bit uneasy. She played with the inside of her coat pockets and moved her feet back and forth.
O.K. Olivia. Where are you going with this sweetie?
“As time went by, I came to respect you. Yes, I will admit that I wanted to kick your ass from here to Queens sometimes and I hated some of the situations that you put me in, but I knew that it would be o.k. You lead and I followed. Our partnership somehow grew into friendship and from friendship to best friend and now I cannot imagine my life without you.”
“Olivia I hate to interrupt but, what is your point?”
“I am getting there! Just wait.”
“Alright my lips are sealed.”
You know what I can’t do this. This is going to ruin everything and I know it!
“Forget it. This was a bad idea. Let’s just go.”
As Olivia starts to walk away, she feels Elliot grab her upper arm to stop her.
“Come on Liv. Just tell me please. It can’t be that bad.”
“Oh yes it can. If I tell you this Elliot it will change everything.”
“No matter what you say Olivia, I am not going anywhere.”
“You might change your mind once I tell you.”
“No I won’t. Now come on. Tell me what has been bothering you.”
Alright Olivia, this is the moment of truth.
“You really want to know why I hate Dani so much.”
“Yes, because it doesn’t make any sense to me. You didn’t mind me being partners with Blain.”
“Blain was a man Elliot. No comparison.”
“Alright now I am confused.”
WOW! Can he really be this clueless when it comes to women!
“I was jealous Elliot! That is why I didn’t like Dani!”
Elliot now understanding what Olivia was getting at and stepped away from her a little.
“Why would you be jealous Liv? She was just a stand in. She wasn’t my permanent partner.”
“OH! MY! GOD! You are so clueless! Do I really have to throw a detective a life line? I AM IN LOVE WITH YOU ELLIOT! There are you happy!”
Just walk away Olivia. Just walk away.
Olivia turns around to leave. She is speed walking. Elliot, once coming back from the shock he had just received, ran after her. Once he reaches her, he pulls on her upper arm, turns her around and lifts her chin in order for him to look into her eyes. They were swelling up with tears.
“Olivia, I don’t know what to say.”
“Don’t say anything. I know that you don't feel the same way and I understand that. I just wanted you to know.” Olivia takes Elliot’s hands away from her face. She looks into his eyes and with her right hand touches his cheek.
“Goodnight Elliot. I’ll see you at work.”
Olivia then turns and walks toward her apartment; leaving Elliot standing alone in the park.
What the hell just happened? Did I just let the woman I love walk away? You idiot Stabler! Run after her and tell her how you feel!
Olivia practically runs home. When she reaches her door, she pulls out her keys and hears the lock unlatch. She opens the door, gets in and slams it shut.
What have I done! I just made the biggest mistake of my life! Good going Olivia. You just ran off the only man you ever loved!
She leans against the wall and as the tears fall, so does she. She slowly sinks to the floor; head in hands.
Then suddenly she hears a knock at the door.
Who the hell could that be?
“What do you want?”
“Liv open the door.”
Part 2: Letting Go
"Elliot please just leave. I need to be alone right now."
"Please Liv. Just let me in so we can talk."
Olivia did not need to hear what she knew Elliot would say. "This is a mistake. Our partnership and our friendship would be ruined." All she wanted to do was wallow in self pity.
"Please Elliot not now."
"Olivia come on. We both know that I am not going to leave. Not to mention that I have a spare key."
shoot! Can this day get any worse?
"Fine!"
Olivia gives in. She slowly turns the locks and opens the door. Olivia has one hand on the door, while the other rested on the door frame blocking the entrance.
"Well are you going to let me in or am I going to have to have this conversation with you and your neighbors?"
Olivia and Elliot both turn around and notice that Mr. Derrick Sampson is standing behind Elliot holding a bag of groceries.
"This fellow isn't bothering you is he?"
Olivia contemplated about saying yes so she could get Elliot out of her door frame. But she decided against it.
"No he isn't. Thank you Mr. Sampson."
"Well alright then. If you need me you know where I live."
"I do thanks. Have a good night."
With that Mr. Sampson gets his keys out and goes into his own apartment and shuts the door. Elliot is still standing in Liv's doorway waiting for her to let him in.
"So..."
"Come in."
Olivia lets Elliot enter her apartment and she shuts the door. Elliot walks over to her living room, takes off his coat and turns to look at Liv.
"So...What do you want to talk about?"
"Are you serious? Liv you tell me you love me and then run off without me even being able to respond."
Olivia is not even looking at Elliot but at the carpet. What can she say to him? How can she explain her feelings to him when she didn't even know herself? The only thing she knew was that she loved him.
"I don't know what to say."
"Don't say anything then. It's my turn to talk." Elliot begins to step a bit closer to Liv before he begins his declaration. I want to be with Olivia so much but now is just not the best time. I need to let her know that I care about her. I just can't tell her I love her. At least not yet. Now how do I do that? O.k. start talking Stabler. "Look Liv I have to admit that I was a bit shocked that you said you loved me but I don't know I guess I never thought I would hear those words again and especially not from you."
"Look Elliot..."
"No let me finish. You and I have been through so much in the last 8 years and we both have had to deal with a lot of crap. Between work, Kathy leaving me and the kids hating me I don't really have the time for anything else. I never thought that you and I would ever be anything more then friends and partners and I...Hell I don't know what I am trying to say."
Olivia knew he was nervous. Elliot always ranted when he was nervous. But the real question was why? If anything Olivia should be the one pacing not Elliot. She is the one that poured her heart out to him and told him she loved him.
"Look Elliot. If it makes you feel any better I am not expecting anything from you. I just wanted to tell you how I felt. I have never felt this way before and it scared me. It still does because I know the dangers of being with your partner and co-worker. I just don't want this to be awkward."
"I think we are a bit to late for that."
They both had to let out a chuckle because deep down both of the detectives knew that they would never be the same again.
"I do care about you Olivia. I just don't think that a relationship, especially with my partner, is a good idea right now. I mean I am still trying to get the relationship with my kids back and Kathy and I are still trying to work out the custody and visits with the kids. My life is just unstable right now. You understand don't you?"
Olivia knew this would happen. She knew telling Elliot how she felt would be a mistake. All she wanted to do right now was crawl under her blankets and cry herself to sleep. As she felt the tears beginning to form, she breathed in deep in order to stop them. Olivia looked at Elliot and crossed her arms.
"Of course I understand. I told you that I wasn't expecting anything from you. I just wanted you to know."
God how many times am I going to repeat that! I just want him gone right now! Please let this be over!
"I really do need to go. Are you sure you're alright?"
"Yeah Elliot. I'm fine."
It was a lie of course but Elliot didn't find it. Once he was satisfied that she would be o.k. He decided to leave her alone and let her sleep.
"Alright then. I really do need to go and you need to sleep. Tomorrow Cragen has us on desk duty so we can catch up on some paper work."
"O.k. I guess I will see you tomorrow."
"Bright and early."
With that Elliot got up and headed for the door. Before he left he turned to Olivia. "Olivia, you know that no matter what I will always be your friend right? I will always be here for you?"
"Yeah I do Elliot." God please leave! I swear I am going to lose it!
"Goodnight Liv."
"Goodnight Elliot."
He took one last look at his partner, opened the door and left. The minute the door closed Olivia couldn't fight the tears anymore. They fell down her face as she walked over to her bedroom and landed on the edge of her bed.
How could I have been so stupid? How could I have even thought that Elliot would want someone like me? Why did I have to fall in love at all? and with my partner no less? Olivia Benson you are such an idiot! Elliot could never love me! Hell no one ever has and no one ever will.
Once Olivia stopped sobbing and the tears were slowing down, she grabbed her shorts and t-shirt she wore to bed and changed. As she tried her best to get tonight’s event out of her head so she could go to sleep, she continued to cry. She knew that the only man she ever loved would never give her the time of day. Not because he didn't care but because of the job and because of his kids. Olivia knew that she had to let him go. The only problem was that she had never been in love before and she didn't have the first clue as to how to go about doing that. All she knew was she had to try because she didn't have a choice.
Part 3: Brooklyn or Manhattan?
Olivia tried her best to stay away from Elliot. She wanted as much distance as possible; at least until she could clear her head and figured out what she was going to do. She still did not know if she could stay at Manhattan SVU. She had received an offer from her friend from Brooklyn SVU to be his new partner and she was seriously contemplating it. At the moment though, she needed to think.
She and Elliot had received a case and both were acting out of place. Once Cragen noticed this, a trip to his office was deemed necessary.
“Benson, Stabler in my office now.”
As soon as they reached Cragen’s office, Elliot shut the door and they stood waiting for Cragen to speak.
“What is the matter with you two? For the past two weeks the two of you have put as much distance between each other as humanly possible.”
“Distance? What do you mean? I don’t think we are being distant.”
“Oh really? What do you call doing your paper work in the interrogation room on your lap top Olivia?”
“Look captain, Elliot and I just wanted to do our work a bit differently that’s all.”
“You are trying to do your work differently. Do I have stupid imprinted on my forehead? I know my own detectives and the last time I checked you two were in sync. Now you cannot stand to be in the same room with each other. Wanna tell me why?”
“No we don’t. Look captain, Elliot and I are sort of going through a rough patch right now. We will work it out.”
“That’s all? You’re going through a rough patch? I really do not need problems among my detectives right now. That brass is already tailing me because of Munch’s comment about Republicans last week. I really do not need them on my ass about disputes as well. You better work it out and I don’t want to see anymore arguments or distancing between you two. Now get back to work.”
Elliot and Olivia left Cragen’s office. Once they cleared from ear shot, Elliot grabbed Olivia by the upper arm gently and whispered in her ear.
“Can I please talk to you for a second?”
“No. We need to get back to work. Now let go of me.”
“Please Liv? We really need to talk.”
“Fine. Where do you want to go?”
“On the roof.”
Olivia and Elliot made their way up to the precinct roof in silence. Once they reached the top, Elliot opened the door and closed it behind them.
“Alright you got me up here. What do you want to talk about?”
“I hate this Liv. I hate it when we are like this.”
“Like what Elliot?”
“What do you mean like what? Liv we can’t even be in the same room together without feeling claustrophobic. I just want us to be friends again. I want us to go to being the way we were before…”
“Before I told you I loved you and you turned me down. But you could kiss a woman that you hardly knew for 6 weeks.”
“That’s not fair. I told you that Dani and I meant nothing to each other.”
“But you kissed her Elliot. But me, a woman who actually loves you and wants to be with you, you won’t give the time of day.”
“I do care about you Olivia. Hell, it’s not like I am not trying. You act as if you could care less if we are partners anymore let alone friends.”
I don’t know if I can do this anymore. It’s too hard! Even seeing him yelling at me still makes me want to kiss him.
“I don’t know what to do Elliot. What do I do?”
“I…I have no idea Liv. I do care about you and I do love you. I just can’t love you the way you want me to.” At least not yet.
“I was offered a position at Brooklyn SVU. Sanders is in need of a new partner.”
Elliot felt a sense of panic. God I don’t want her to leave. She is all I have left.
“Wow! So does this mean that you want to leave Manhattan SVU?”
“I am seriously thinking about it. Honestly Elliot, the papers are already filled out. I just need to drop them off and talk to Cragen.”
“Why are you telling me this Liv?”
“I don’t know. I guess I was hoping you would convince me to stay.”
Deja vu! I can’t tell her to stay; even though every part of my body wants to kiss the hell out of her and take her right then and there. I want to kiss her so bad. I just wish that I could hold her and tell her that everything will be o.k. and that I am and always will be here for her, but I can’t.
“You know that I can’t do that Liv. As painful as this is for me to say, it has to be your choice.”
“Why is it painful for you to say?”
“Because I know you Liv. I know that if the paper worked is filled out and you are ready to take the leap, you will. I can only say that I would miss you and I...I don’t know.”
“What Elliot?”
“I just don’t want to loose you again. Outside of work, you are all that I have left. I know that this is a repeat and you have heard it all before but, I am afraid.”
“What are you afraid of Elliot? Are you afraid that I will finally move on and forget all about this pain and hollowness that I feel? I cannot keep sacrificing my happiness in order for others to be happy. I am sick of it!”
“I am afraid that if you leave Liv I am going to be lost.”
Olivia was not expecting an answer like that. If anything she was expecting silence.
“God I am so lost. For the first time in my life Elliot I am completely and utterly lost.”
“What do you want to do Liv?”
“I don’t know.”
“Promise me that whatever you decide you won’t shut me out?”
“In order for me to move on Elliot, I really don’t see any other way.”
Without thinking, Olivia had made her choice. She was leaving behind Manhattan SVU, her friends and everything that she has ever known in order to move forward with her life.
Elliot knew by the way she said this she had made her decision.
“So I guess this means you’re leaving then?”
“I have to Elliot. It is the only way I can move on and try and put the topic of us behind me. I need to try and start over without you. I’m sorry.”
As soon as she finished her last words, Olivia stood up from her seat on the bench, walked past Elliot and whispered goodbye.
The next thing Elliot knew, Olivia was transferred to Brooklyn SVU, had moved to where Elliot assumed was an apartment closer to her new location and out of his life for good. All he felt was emptiness. He felt as though he had lost the best thing that has ever happened to him. But will he ever get it back? Will he ever get her back?

