personal i think any judge that chose ricickiejoleen to go over meg allison should be fired comeon rickiejoleen sang with feeling and heart and in a way connected with everyone if these lame judges had given us all a chance to vote rickiejoleen would still be there. nashville star needs to go back to it's original format let the judges commintate let the audience vote cause thes judges have no idea what talent is. Bring back phil vasser and bret micheals at least they could hear talent.