Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Why is Kristen not in the top 3?
USA Network Forums > Past Programs > Nashville Star > Season 4 Contestants > Kristen McNamara
Cindy1128
I'm sorry, but I don't get it. I don't mean any disrespect, but Kristen is way better than Nicole, and even Casey. It should be between Chris Young & Kristen McNamara. If we are truly only speaking on preformance ability & talent, and if we are being honest...it should be Chris & Kristen.
Pop
and IF frogs had wings, they wouldn't bump their ass when they jumped....
Sportsknight2
Don't beat a dead horse, Kristen did not get enough votes and Nicole did! I may not like the final 3 either but all three earned their spots. Live with it and move on.
jsteudl024
Quote:

and IF frogs had wings, they wouldn't bump their ass when they jumped....




And your sure of this.... I guess that means the experiment worked.

I'm not gonna have frogs splattered all over my windshield am I?
jsteudl024
Little late to be complaining don't you think?
Did you vote for her or did you just recently hear she was on the show?
theOtherChris
well to quote Admin: "Not enough votes"
LetsTailG8
Quote:

I'm sorry, but I don't get it. I don't mean any disrespect, but Kristen is way better than Nicole, and even Casey. It should be between Chris Young & Kristen McNamara. If we are truly only speaking on preformance ability & talent, and if we are being honest...it should be Chris & Kristen.




You are asking for honesty while you don't practice any yourself. You are clearly biased or simply delusional if you think Kristen is even in the same statosphere with Casey. You might have a basis for a debate if you confined it to Nicole, but HONESTLY Nicole presented herself much better than Kristin, chose better songs and performed them better than Kristin.
Bonnie
And your sure of this.... I guess that means the experiment worked.
I'm not gonna have frogs splattered all over my windshield am I?


No, just dancing bunnies LOL!
jsteudl024
Quote:


You are asking for honesty while you don't practice any yourself. You are clearly biased or simply delusional if you think Kristen is even in the same statosphere with Casey. You might have a basis for a debate if you confined it to Nicole, but HONESTLY Nicole presented herself much better than Kristin, chose better songs and performed them better than Kristin.




LTG8 The person you are replying to is an American consumer who probably buys 10 or more CD's a year. I can see how you feel you have been attacked personally by her remarks about Casey and feel you need to strike back.

BREATHE LTG. Count to 10. Let it go. You wouldn't want this person going into WalMart or wherever, seeing Casey's CD and NOT wanting to buy it because some jerk ripped them a new you know what on an internet message board. That's not fair to them or Casey.

Kristen is spelled with an e just so you know. Don't start with the impersonating a message board psychologist crap either, I'll have to scounge up another degree.
You can't change the world by hollering at it.
jsteudl024
Actually I'm fine with dancing bunnies they're pretty cute.
LetsTailG8
Quote:

LTG8 The person you are replying to is an American consumer who probably buys 10 or more CD's a year. I can see how you feel you have been attacked personally by her remarks about Casey and feel you need to strike back.

BREATHE LTG. Count to 10. Let it go. You wouldn't want this person going into WalMart or wherever, seeing Casey's CD and NOT wanting to buy it because some jerk ripped them a new you know what on an internet message board. That's not fair to them or Casey.

Kristen is spelled with an e just so you know. Don't start with the impersonating a message board psychologist crap either, I'll have to scounge up another degree. Y
ou can't change the world by hollering at it.




If you check her bio, you'll see the obvious bias. I doubt she buys any country CDs and would not buy Casey's anyway. Besides, she is the one that is here to tear down the Nicole and Casey because she misguidedly thinks this will make Kristen look better.
jsteudl024
Quote:


If you check her bio, you'll see the obvious bias. I doubt she buys any country CDs and would not buy Casey's anyway. Besides, she is the one that is here to tear down the Nicole and Casey because she misguidedly thinks this will make Kristen look better.




I saw the bio and realize that her daughter is Kristen's best friend. Still why would you think she doesn't buy country music CD's because she lives in C.A. in the Nappa Valley. TailG8 that's where the happy cows come from or some of them anyway. I have been really impressed with Casey especially over the last two weeks. The man can flat out sing. I would say I voted for him but the Chris Young fans would run me out of here. Actually I split 35 votes two ways. He deserves to be in the final three he has earned it. I am a Kristen McNamara fan but I have never once said she was robbed or cheated or that the voters are tone deaf or must be stupid. Kristen does have an incredible voice. I don't think she brought her A game to the show. Nerves whatever! The people in Matt's hometown want to adopt her. They loved her performance there. I guess for her it's a matter of feeling comfortable. I really don't have a bad thing to say about any of the contestants and I wish them all the best. I really hope something breaks for Jayron that man can flat out sing too.
LetsTailG8
Jack,
Let's take a trip in the way back machine to just before the second episode.

http://mboard.usanetwork.com/showflat.ph...true#Post180023
jsteudl024
I hate that machine. Do you have any dramamine?
What am I looking for? Oh yeah dramamine.
Besides that?
LetsTailG8
Quote:

I hate that machine. Do you have any dramamine?
What am I looking for? Oh yeah dramamine.
Besides that?




You can't see anything with your head in the sand. Denial is a horribly disabilatating disease.
Bonnie
I'm not Jack but I did find this statement by you back then:
"I'm not betting anything on anybody because I don't have a dog in this fight. I'm just sitting back and observing what's happening. I'm sorry you are so offended when other people don't see it the way you do."

and I did chuckle - because you certainly DID get a 'dog in the fight' later on it seems? Casey. At least you have fought a lot of people on here about him. I like him fine so don't jump on me....I'm just making an observation.
jsteudl024
Excuse me! N...a Please! I'm not denying anything. What is it exactly you want me to look at. Something I said or something you said? A little help please. If I'm in the wrong I'll be the first to apologize.
LetsTailG8
Quote:

Excuse me! N...a Please! I'm not denying anything. What is it exactly you want me to look at. Something I said or something you said? A little help please. If I'm in the wrong I'll be the first to apologize.




Never mind. I learned a long time ago to never try to teach a pig to sing. It's a waste of your time and it frustrates the pig.
jsteudl024
Your vocal coach said that huh? Right before he quit!
nottonedeaf
I do think Kristen is better than Nicole, but then I also thought Melanie was better than Nicole-but then I thought Matt was better than Nicole. But-I must confess that although I do think Kristen must have a strong, beautiful voice, I do not feel that it showed in her performances. We only got glimpses of what it could be. I liked her personality, and I believe in a studio she'd be great, but let's face it - go back and review the performance and she was sharp or flat on many notes. I do believe, however, it was due to nerves. As for not Kristen being better than Casey . . . Can't go there. Casey's voice is spectacular. No one, not even Chris Young (who I love) comes close. Performance wise, he's right on cue-no sharps, no flats and great quality (regardless of nerves). You may not like him as your personal favorite, but I find it hard to believe that anyone could deny that the boy can sing. FYI: I REALLY felt it should've been Casey, Matt, and Chris. The winner???? Toss a coin. I'm Casey supporter, but I must confess that I threw some calls Matt and Chris's way. I don't dislike Nicole-I'm just baffled.
lucygoosy101
I have a question... Several weeks ago there was someone that kept saying on a post that they had something to loose or something at stake does anyone remember that?
hallomar
" Nicole presented herself much better than Kristin, chose better songs and performed them better than Kristin. "

Are you high? Nicole coudn't spitshine Kristen's boots. She was off on every song she did, and, (except for "Give 'em something to talk about" which she couldn't do right), her choices of songs were awful! I bit my tongue for five minutes before I typed this, because I try not to participate in this further than 24 hours after each weeks show. But, I just couldn't resist this time. Sorry.
jsteudl024
As my mother used to say..."It's better to look like a fool than to open you mouth and prove it" Dear ole Mom I miss her.
hallomar
Always like your posts, lol.
jsteudl024
You know I really didn't think Nicole was bad at all. I think they all are under allot of pressure and that effects their performances. Chris seemed to cope with it the best but I'm sure even he wasn't comfortable.

TailG8 probably feels he's in the middle of a gang fight and forgot his gang.
Bonnie
Quote:

I have a question... Several weeks ago there was someone that kept saying on a post that they had something to loose or something at stake does anyone remember that?


A lot of people say that on here...was it when WVG and LetsTailG8 were fighting in a thread? Something about LTG8 representing Jayron and now maybe Casey??
j007
Kristen was the only female I believe had a chance at it this season but wife and I had her at number 4 with Chris,Casey and Matt ahead of her-my mind she ort to be on the Nashville Star tour.I think it very strange that Nicole beat out Torres and McNamara--and real unlikely that she beat out Matt.Rumors abound about fixes as it was deemed Matt might be hard to work with at the Record Label???
USA_Admin
Quote:

Kristen was the only female I believe had a chance at it this season but wife and I had her at number 4 with Chris,Casey and Matt ahead of her-my mind she ort to be on the Nashville Star tour.I think it very strange that Nicole beat out Torres and McNamara--and real unlikely that she beat out Matt.Rumors abound about fixes as it was deemed Matt might be hard to work with at the Record Label???




I heard a rumor that fewer people for Matt, and that's why left. But your rumor makes a lot more sense, since jeopodizing the integrity of the show to fix who finishes in third place seems so logical.
xxsvufan08xx
Out of all the nashville star people kristen was my favorite and i wish that she wasn't voted off and she would have won!!
jsteudl024
I love her too! What a gal!
georgectv
Quote:

I heard a rumor that fewer people for Matt, and that's why left. But your rumor makes a lot more sense, since jeopodizing the integrity of the show to fix who finishes in third place seems so logical.




lolol good one Admin! Nothing like an Admin with a sense of humor to liven up the board

And you have a great point too!
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.