She won me over last week - it's a shame she's gone... I know we'll see more of her in the future. From one artist to another - Melanie, if you see this - don't give up - you own that stage - you just don't know it...

ECW

I love the show. It has gone down hill. Where is the entertainmen? Folks like Matt Lindahl made the show worth watching. Original I think not I could go to any piano bar and here these song. Why not have orininal week 2 or 3 times per season so we can really here what these people are made of. Judging left to the audience is crazy its only a popularity contest. Why not allow the judges who are the professional have some part of the vote. IE dancing with the stars, its not the best solution but alteast the pro have part of the decision.

AMEN!

Melanie was the best girl on Nashville Star and it's crap that she was kicked off and she's was so much better than Nicole and how does she get kicked off but you watch she'll get a record deal!!!