Melanie was my favorite perfomer on Nashville Star. She has a great voice and she will really go far in country music.

I was stuck between Melanie and Chris. Both are strong performers and have alot of stage presence. She definitely was the strongest female. I don't know why she was voted off but the fans voted and so it is. I hope Nicole can pull off a coo because between her and Kristin, she is definitely the better performer. I do wish Melanie lots of luck and I don't think she will have to worry - she has a beautiful voice, she herself is beautiful and there is always tomorrow!